India-Pakistan’s lessons for peace in North Korea

Courtesy The Washington Post-

Retired CIA director Gen. Michael V. Hayden recently told New Yorker writer Robin Wright that any diplomatic solution “will have to, in one way or another, concede North Korea’s nuclear status. Nothing else is possible.” As a former deputy chief of staff of U.S. Forces Korea, he knows the territory.

I am a retired intelligence officer with some perspective on Korea. I cannot claim Mr. Hayden’s breadth of experience but I agree we must accept that North Korea has achieved nuclear deterrent status. From Pyongyang’s perspective, this is regime survival. The best analogy is Pakistan’s pursuit of a nuclear deterrent against India. Both Pakistan and North Korea acted from recognition of hopeless conventional-war inferiority and need for an asymmetric option.

The Kim regime is repellant. It does not merit U.S. recognition but it is a fact of international life. The United States should seek confidential negotiations with China to secure a mutual guarantee to jointly present to the U.N. Security Council. Beijing would sell it to Pyongyang, Washington to Seoul and Tokyo. Not conceding the de jure status of the Kim regime, the United States would agree to de facto accept its nuclear arsenal. In exchange, North Korea would accept a weapons freeze at their current level and delivery capability enforced by an International Atomic Energy Agency inspection regime and including a prohibition on exporting nuclear weapons technology.

We also should pursue with China a four-cornered hotline with North Korea and South Korea, like the one the United States helped India and Pakistan establish.

Previous articleSaudi Arabia is moving to rein in its religious police. Sort of.
Next articleThe Enduring Hypocrisy of Nuclear No First Use
The Islamabad Policy Institute (IPI) is a nonpartisan, independent policy research institute based in Islamabad. Our goal is to undertake in-depth analysis of challenges and choices confronting Pakistan. We aim to help policymakers and public better understand the world, region and Pakistan-specific challenges and opportunities. We make efforts to engage government, civil society, private sector, media, academia in open debates and dialogue on the most significant developments in national and international affairs. We envision contributing to policy-making through periodic policy-papers putting forward policy-recommendations developed in collaboration with experts and stakeholders in each area. IPI takes no institutional position on policy issues.


Please enter your comment!
Please enter your name here